Cognitive strategies of analogical reasoning in design: Differences between expert and novice designers
MetadataShow full item record
This study investigates differences in analogical reasoning among first, second, and fourth year students and expert architects. Participants took part in an experiment consisting of four tasks: rating source examples, selecting a source domain, explaining their selection, and designing a bus stop. The results indicate significant differences among participants with respect to their soundness ratings. The results also show significant relation between level of expertise and participants' selection of source categories, the stated reasons for their selection, and the type of similarity they established between source and target. We conclude that experts preferred ‘mental hops’ while first year students preferred ‘mental leaps.’ Second and fourth year students preferred neither ‘mental leaps’ nor ‘mental hops’ but to literally copy the sources.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Secure urban environments by design:analysis of Konak square design through"crime prevention through environmental design (CPTED) princioples Deniz, Deniz (İzmir Institute of Technology, 2007)Better design can play a crucial role for reducing crime and creating secureurban environments. In this regard, planners and designers have begun to acknowledge the importance of Crime Prevention through Environmental ...
User-centered design criteria in automobile design with a case study of automobile dashboard design Arslan, Fatih (Izmir Institute of Technology, 2006)Our era provides us enormous changes and unforeseen advancements in technology, which lead to specific changes in economic and socio-cultural values. As a result of this shift, consumer.s need and expectations have changed ...
Understanding the relationship among sustainability, industrial design and service sysstem design: co-design in Aalborg to access local food Dilek, Özgün (Izmir Institute of Technology, 2012)Design has been a structural part of the industrialization processes and has inadvertently contributed to the creation of the current ecological problems of the planet. So far industrial design discipline has been producing ...